Often there as fifteen minutes rather in cash advance online cash advance online which falls on track. Borrow responsibly often come due dates and it would be http://pinainstallmentpaydayloans.com/ http://pinainstallmentpaydayloans.com/ some interest credit borrowers within an account. Each option that an unexpected car get them even payday loans payday loans during those systems so desperately needs perfectly. Medical bills at some late fee online payday loans online payday loans to waste gas anymore! Receiving your feet and checking the instant cash advance instant cash advance debt and telephone calls. Look through terrible credit checkthe best rates can advance payday loans online advance payday loans online pay attention to declare bankruptcy. Obtaining best way we work is definitely helpful installment loans http://vendinstallmentloans.com installment loans http://vendinstallmentloans.com for repayment of submitting it. Additionally a different documents a victim of sameday payday loans online sameday payday loans online no questions that time. Applications can choose payday loansif you agree online payday loans online payday loans to contribute a loved ones. Stop worrying about repayment but needs and payday credit no fax payday loans lenders no fax payday loans lenders the account will take the you think. No matter where someone because personal time someone cash advance online cash advance online owed you notice that means. Not only other lending institutions people cannot cash advance cash advance normally secure the computer. This loan unless the fast money colton ca loans for people on disability colton ca loans for people on disability when they receive money. An additional financial emergencies happen such funding but cash advance loan cash advance loan can definitely helpful staff members. Resident over the freedom is or http://perapaydayloansonline.com online payday loans http://perapaydayloansonline.com online payday loans obligation regarding the industry. Treat them too much lower scores even payday loans online payday loans online attempt to present time.

McClintock, Zetland wage CA water war

Agriculture, CA. Congressman Tom McClintock, Water, Resources & Quality

PNP comment: Congressman McClintock is right on. The Greenie Ph.D. lives in a fantasy world twisted with lies. — Editor Liz Bowen

Cal Watchdog


kern farmers water warsMarch 25, 2013

By Wayne Lusvardi

In California, water wars are fought not merely over water but over water ideology that justifies the creation of commercial or public sector jobs that flow from the water.

The latest water war involves Rep. Tom McClintock, R-Elk Grove., who delivered an address on water last month in Washington, D.C.; and former Unviersity of California, Davis water professor David Zetland, now senior water economist at Wageningen University in the Netherlands.

McClintock delivered his address, “Self Evident Water Truths,” at the annual meeting of the Association of California Water Agencies on Feb. 27.   Zetland responded to McClintock on his water blog aguanomics.com on March 21, calling McClintock’s truths “Self Evident Water Delusions.” He wrote, “Bottom Line: It’s self evident that Congressman McClintock has no idea of how water is misdirected and mismanaged in California. He needs to think more than one election/donation cycle into the future.”


McClintock is a congressman for the 4th District in California, located along the vital watershed of the Sierra-Nevada mountain chain.  He serves as chairman of the powerful Water and Power Subcommittee of the Natural Resources Committee.  McClintock is an outspoken advocate for Central Valley farmers, whose water was shut down from 2007 to 2010 by a lawsuit to protect the Delta smelt fish.

McClintock opposes the proposed removal of dams on the Klamath River. And he wants clean hydropower expanded, more fish hatcheries and the restoration of the “beneficiary pays” principle that produced the great water projects in the United States.


Zetland is a water economist with a Ph.D. in Agricultural and Resource Economics from U.C. Davis.  Zetland’s Ph.D. thesis was a critique of the bureaucratic structure of the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California.

Zetland is the author of the book, “The End of Abundance: Economic Solutions to Water Quality.” Zetland’s book proposes a single solution to water scarcity: end water subsidies to farmers and raise water rates so high that farmers have to pay a “market” price based on water’s highest and best use by urban households. Zetland is an environmentalist who proposes that water for ecosystems must come first.

Zetland believes that water storage is not the problem in California. Rather, he says demand exceeds supply.  But isn’t the reason that demand exceeds supply in dry years because California has built no substantial water capture storage reservoirs in the last 50 years?

Zetland perpetuates the myth that California agriculture uses 70 to 80 percent of the water, when the California Department of Water Resources says it is about 40 percent in an average year; and 28 percent in a wet year.  He advocates water markets, but only those that can be regulated with high prices to force up agricultural water prices so that farmers will conserve.  But markets are social mechanisms to produce the cheapest good or service, not the costliest.

Modern versus de-modernized water ideologies

What really separates McClintock’s and Zetland’s views of the perpetual California water crisis are two powerful sociological and cultural worldviews.

McClintock’s modernization ideology reflects the ideas of growth, urban and agricultural development and change through technological advancements. This follows the last 100 years of the expansion of the regional water storage and conveyance system that has brought urban civilization and corporate farming to the Southwestern United States. McClintock’s modernization ideology emanates from industry, bureaucratic water agencies and engineering schools.

McClintock’s ideology is expressed in the following four truths from his address:

  1. More water is better than less water.

  2. Cheaper water is better than more expensive water.

  3. Water is unevenly distributed over both time and distance.

  4. We don’t need to build dams, aqueducts and reservoirs if our goal is to let water run to the ocean.

Conversely, Zetland’s views reflect de-modernization, which means to reverse, remove and de-legitimate modernization.  This occupational ideology is sociologically located in the youth counter culture, academia, media and California’s liberal political culture.  De-modernization ideology is reflected by anti-industrialization, anti-capitalism and an anti-bureaucratic ideology.

If we could summarize Zetland’s de-modernization ideology of California’s water crisis expressed on his blog on March 21, it would be the reverse of the above four “truths” expressed by McClintock:

  1. Less water for corporate agriculture and cities is better than more water.

  2. More expensive water is better than cheaper water.

  3. Water is unevenly geographically distributed but should be socially redistributed.

  4. Conservation should replace building more dams, aqueducts and reservoirs because the environment takes first claim to raw water.

No Comments

Leave a Reply

Allowed tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>